« Some other goodness about America | Main | Bush, the Great Commuter »

Letters to the Editor on the Libby Commutation

A lot of letters condemning the President's commutation of the Libby sentence appeared in The New York Times yesterday. A couple said the commutation was the right thing to do, but most didn't. Here's a particularly pointed one, that calls out the hypocrisy and double standard the President has applied in the Libby case. Clearly, there is a double standard in play here, and the President abused his power (again):

To the Editor:

When George W. Bush was governor of Texas, he presided over more than 150 executions. In more than one-third of the cases — 57 in all — lawyers representing condemned inmates asked then-Governor Bush for a commutation of sentence, so that the inmates would serve life in prison rather than face execution.

Some of these inmates had been represented by lawyers who slept during trials. Some were mentally retarded. Some were juveniles at the time they committed the crime for which they were sentenced to death.

In all these cases, Governor Bush refused to commute their sentences, saying that the inmates had had full access to the judicial system.

I. Lewis Libby Jr. had the best lawyers money can buy. His crime cannot be attributed to youth or retardation. He has expressed no remorse whatsoever for lying to a grand jury or participating in the administration's effort to mislead the American people about the war in Iraq. President Bush's commutation of Mr. Libby's sentence is certainly legal, but it just as surely offends the fundamental constitutional value of equality.

Because President Bush signed a commutation, a rich and powerful man will spend not a day in prison, while 57 poor and poorly connected human beings died because Governor Bush refused to lift a pen for them.

David R. Dow

Houston, July 3, 2007

The writer is a professor at the University of Houston Law Center who represents death row inmates, including several who sought commutation from then-Governor Bush.

More pointed commentary on the Libby commutation from someone who is well versed in our republican form of government. Thanks to George for the pointer to this one.

Get GLONO merch!