« Smile! | Main | Generals: Time to zip it up, Dick »

Al Franken + Fourth Amendment vs. Patriot Act

This is awesome. The Washington Independent Al Franken Reads the 4th Amendment to Justice Department Official:

Franken, who opened by acknowledging that unlike most of his colleagues in the Senate, he's not a lawyer, but according to his research "most Americans aren't lawyers" either, said he'd also done research on the Patriot Act and in particular, the "roving wiretap" provision that allows the FBI to get a warrant to wiretap a an unnamed target and his or her various and changing cell phones, computers and other communication devices.

Noting that he received a copy of the Constitution when he was sworn in as a senator, he proceeded to read it to Kris, emphasizing this part: "no Warrants shall issue but upon probable cause, supported by Oath or affirmation, and particularly describing the place to be searched, and the persons or things to be seized."

"That's pretty explicit language," noted Franken, asking Kris how the "roving wiretap" provision of the Patriot Act can meet that requirement if it doesn't require the government to name its target.

Kris looked flustered and mumbled that "this is surreal," apparently referring to having to respond to Franken's question. "I would defer to the other branch of government," he said, referring to the courts, prompting Franken to interject: "I know what that is."

Kris explained that the courts have held that the law's requirements that the person be described, though not named, is sufficient to meet the demands of the Constitution. That did not appear to completely satisfy Franken's concerns.

The language of the Fourth Amendment is so clear and explicit, yet nobody seems to give a flying fuck about it. How can these kinds of laws pass muster with the Supreme Court?

Advertisement

Comments

How? Because it has the word "Patriot" in it. That means it's good for America, see?

I'd find it pretty surreal, too, if I were getting my ass raked over the coals by Senator Stuart Smalley.

Post a comment

Get GLONO merch!